Respond to these two post at least 100-150 words each.
Respond to these two post at least 100-150 words each.
Two students respond to the folloing writing Essay, your job is to respond these two post at least 100-150 words each. Your posts should briefly evaluate the quality of the organization of their responses, focusing in particular on the organization of their supporting paragraphs. Are they making effective use of transitions? Do they include strong topic sentences? What could they do to improve their organization?
The two sudent must follow these structure, primary post should include an introduction. that introduces the topic and ends with a clearly worded, 1-2 sentence thesis statement. Links to an external site. Each supporting paragraph (there should be at least 3) should begin with a strong topic sentence. and should incorporate evidence, including direct quotations from the short stories as needed to support your argument. Direct quotations should be incorporated using the quotation sandwich method and proper MLA in-text citations. The post should also contain a strong conclusion. Links to an external site.
1. Morgan reflects, “My ancestors have come from all over. These are the only people in this country who are not immigrants. This is their home.” Morgan means that of all the current residents in the US, the Native Americans are the only citizens who did not immigrate to this country. Most U.S. citizens had ancestors that immigrated to this country less than 300 years ago. The Native Americans have been citizens of the United States long before that. Morgan’s reflection suggests a belief that this land belongs to Native Americans just as much as it belongs to any other American in this country. Junior also feels that he has as much claim to the land as any other American living in the country, which should mean that he should feel safe and comfortable when travelling throughout its land. However, Junior states, “Travelling between Reardan and Wellpinit, between the little white town and the reservation, I always felt like a stranger” (Alexie, 118). Even though Reardan and Wellpinit are bordering towns, just by crossing the border Junior is made to feel like he doesn’t belong. The land which was solely the home of Junior’s ancestors can now make Junior feel like he doesn’t belong just by travelling a few miles away from his home. In the documentary Morgan states,
Even though the Navajo have billions of gallons of freshwater flowing right through the reservation, Uncle same never gave them the rights to most of it. To make matters worse their H20 ends up watering desert cities in Arizona and Nevada (30 Days: Living on the Navajo Indian Reservation, 2008)
This shows that even though the land is their home and even though they are U.S. citizens, the federal government does not treat Native Americans as well, or as fairly, as citizens not on the reservations. All of the water that is from the reservation land is taken and given to large cities in the surrounding areas which shows that to the federal government, the reservations and their people are an afterthought and are not viewed as important as the non-Native Americans that live in other parts of the country. Not only do the Native Americans have their water taken from them, they are not even given enough for them to take care of themselves, which has resulted in some reservations not having any running water. Running, clean, water should be a basic human right for any citizen of this country. However, this example helps point to the lack of humanity and dignity afforded Native Americans.
Works Cited
Alexie, S. (2007). The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian. Little, Brown and Company, New York: NY.
Cappiello, Marcellus. 30 Days S03 E06 Life On An Indian Reservation. Morgan Spurlock ENG 103 class. 2018. Accessed 30 Oct, 2018.
2. In 30 Days, Morgan lived with the Dennison family in the Navajo Reservation in New Mexico. In those 30 days he was one of them, and at the same time he was the minority. Morgan met with a reservation of great people that lacked jobs, abundance of alcoholism, and some homes did not even had electricity and running water. He reflected on the thought that, Native Americans were the first people to ever live in The United States, they did not migrated from another country like everyone else. Morgan’s thought means that the mistreatment and oblivion that Native Americans receive from the modernized westerned need to stop. Native Americans should not be living in such poor conditions with not enough opportunities, moreover; not lose their loved culture and heritage. In comparison, Junior in many occasions is portrayed as hating his “rez” for its overall poor conditions and in fact he decides to leave, however; when he recapacites he does believe there could be a balance between the two worlds, just as the Dennison’s think.
At the moment Morgan met members of the reservation, he instantly felt welcomed and even though the Navajo community was facing several difficulties, Morgan recalls their good spirits; despite worrisome in the back of their minds. As shown in the episode, the reservation still remains faithful to their past, including rituals and prayers that keeps them positive and with hope for the future. Nonetheless, the Navajo nation is going through very critical conditions regarding job opportunities, Morgan was surprised when he discovered that there were only 25 job listings for around 200k people, and that the unemployment rate was over 60% (“30 Days”). In result, people work in other states outside of the reservation to be able to sustain their families. In 30 Days, one of Morgan co-workers states,”Learn from the white men and come back to help your own” (25:59). Most Navajo people no matter the problems, are willing to come back to their homes with more aptitude, due to the simple reason that it is their home. People know that the modernized western world will not overcome their attachment to their culture and heritage.
In contrast, Junior wanted to leave his “rez” succeed and not comeback, still; this thoughts surged when something about the reservation disappointed him in a specific moment, and at negative times Junior did not seemed so attached to his culture. Junior’s disappointment and hate towards the “rez” was frequent, the book portrays Junior as impulsive and emotional when disillusionment and the remainder of how poor he is “rez” comes at his way, Junior expresses, “And let me tell you, that old, old, old decrepit geometry book hit my heart with the force of a nuclear bomb (31). Junior was extremely sad to find out that he was using the same textbooks as his parents, it made him realize again, in the extreme poor conditions he was living. Further, his will to leave accumulating and the detachment to his culture showing.
Still, in ocassions, Junior does consider he needs to find a balance between the two worlds, as the Dennison’s mentality is set. In the book, Junior is aware of his two selves and he knows it cannot last forever, Junior claims, “I was half Indian in one place and half white in the other” (118). Junior knows he should find a common ground with his two worlds to be able to live well and succeed, moreover; that is what the Dennison’s suggest that needs to occur in the Navajo nation to improve their ways of life.
In brief, 30 Days and The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian share a message that, the western modernized world should not forget about Native American nations, and their need to step out of their unfairly poor living conditions. Subsequently, non-Native Americans ought to learn about Native American culture and heritage, since it is a fundamental part of the culture and history of America.
Works Cited
Alexie, Sherman.The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian. Art by Ellen Forney, Little, Brown and Company, 2007
“Living on the Navajo Indian Reservation.” 30 Days, season 3, episode 6, hosted by Morgan Spurlock, 2008. Accessed 31 Oct. 2018.
