Module 7 – Discussion: Modern Tragedy
Module 7 – Discussion: Modern Tragedy
Respond to this discussion activity by constructing a one-paragraph argument about one of the following topics:
- A motif is an element, a type of device, incident or formula found in literature. The term is also applied to the frequent repetition of a significant phrase, set description, or image in a single work. (Theme is sometimes used interchangeably with motif, but we will continue to use theme to refer to the overall claim or doctrine that a work is designed to incorporate.) In Antigone, for example, suicide is a recurring motif. Fences also incorporates recurring references, images and phrases. As discussed in Question 1, athletic pursuits are one dominant motif. Identify and explain the significance of another motif.
- In his essay, “Tragedy and the Common Man,” Arthur Miller argues that tragedy is not pessimistic. Why does Miller see tragedy as optimistic? Taken as a whole, do you interpret Fences as optimistic or pessimistic?
Once you have selected a topic:
- Make a claim in response to one of the topics above.
- Add evidence to support your claim in the form of a quotation to illustrate the point you are making.
- Add analysis by explaining how your quote proves or illustrates your claim.
